Sunday, March 1, 2009

Hunger~Film Review

The Turner Prize has never really rocked my boat.

Perhaps it’s too many installations that make me go, “WTF?” when I see them, wondering how on earth a huge monetary prize is awarded to that particular artist. Steve McQueen is one of those Turner Prize winners, and, he’s moved his focus to film; a decision for which I am thankful.

McQueen has made his first film, one that is riveting in both its subject matter and in the filming process itself. ‘Hunger’ covers the last months of IRA activist, Bobby Sands (Michael Fassbender). Sands was part of a group of prisoners in 1981 at the (in)famous Maze Prison in Northern Ireland, during the height of ‘The Troubles’. They had lost their political prisoner status, and were now simply terrorists held by their ‘enemy’--the British Crown. Protests were staged in the prison on a regular basis, with the men refusing to shower or bathe or wear clothing. They chose to make their jail cells places of horror, including piles of uneaten food, and excrement smeared walls. Both sides hated each other with bone deep hate, choosing to strike against the other side whenever possible.

I remember my Gran speaking with ice edged distain in her voice of the English and how they treated the Irish. She’d tell me of how they had driven her grandparents out of Ireland during the Great Famine, how they starved and suffered in the ships bringing them to America. She loathed the English (even as she taught me the proper English way to have tea) and had no logical reason why. It is something I've seen more than once, this long-standing hard-eyed fury.  I met a Northern Irish waitress last summer, who told me of how she was a new immigrant (read hoped not to be found after her visa ran out) and her life in Belfast. “On Sunday, we’d lob rocks at the Proddie kids.” she said. When I questioned her as to why, she said, “I’ve no idea. It’s something you did.”

Is the hatred DNA locked? Is it generational, with the original flash points long ago, and far away? So long ago, no one knows why they still fight, it’s become something you...do without questioning the reason behind the action, the words, the emotions.

The film does not vilianise nor make heroes of either side, it only points out the events of the H Block hunger strike. Both sides were reduced to a life within the walls, and it shows how hate and anger can erode a soul. McQueen never makes this a martyrdom for the strikers, nor a statement of justification for the prison guards and warden.  Instead, he gives us the facts, and allows us to make our own decisions.  He takes on the role of storyteller, and it is a role he wears well.

It is harsh, brutal at times, almost unbearable to watch. McQueen makes great use of long static shots (the conversation between Sands and a priest is 21 minutes long, and filmed in an uninterrupted take--breathtaking film perfection) and shows us, with the dearth of dialogue, how sound or silence can be used as a weapons. It’s very effective as a filming tool.

There are crafted juxtapositions through out, from the sight of a British policeman quietly sobbing behind a wall as prisoners run a gauntlet while being beaten, to the cruel reality of Sands’ existence and the almost reverence shown in the kind way he was treated by those same guards as he lay dying.

Gandhi used starvation as a tool to passively resist, relying, I believe, on the world eye to cause things to change, to prevent him from dying. Bobby Sands did not have that same stay of death. Fassbender’s image at the end is turn your head away painful. This film is an uncompromising view of what humans are capable of; in violence, in decency, in using their own lives as a means of protest.

I watched and wondered--would I have that kind of belief in my cause that I'd give over my life?  It's a question I think McQueen wants us to ask ourselves, one whose answer may surprise us once it's known.







Hunger, directed by Steve McQueen, written by Steve McQueen and Edna Walsh. In limited release in the US on March 20, 2009. Rated ‘R’ for nudity and violence.

6 comments:

Rebekah said...

I emailed the link to two guys already. Now I want to see it.

The history behind this isn't something I've read, and you know I'm a glutton for information.*

MMMM Irishmen


____
* plus Mom's Cadbury Roses.

Cormac Brown said...

Ah yes, the English Government, who took "divide and conquer" to its ultimate level. And we're still paying for their brand of colonialism in Afghanistan, as well as all the fun with India and Pakistan.

harrietv said...

Well, that certainly confused me! Steve McQueen, in my memory, is the hottie I loved from his TV series long before he made films. And he died almost thirty years ago.

No, I don't think hatred is in the DNA; you just have to get to the kids in the right way.

See the last section of
http://l-empress.liscious.net/older/005229.html
which I wrote about five years ago. It's the sort of thing that gives one hope.

Anonymous said...

not wishing to start an argument re Northern Ireland Cormac... but the Catholics originally asked the British army to go to NI to help stop their persecution by the proddies. This they tried to do until sinn fein or the IRA decided they had enough fire power to take the job on themselves meaning they used their own brand of fighting planting bombs threatening their own kind often innocent people and killing and maiming. Those same soldiers who were welcomed with open arms initially became a target as to try and get them out they took the offensive and claimed to be Irish rather than British. This violence was carried over to the mainland... remember the bombings in Birmingham UK, Harrods in London full of christmas shoppers and many more where innocent men women and children were killed by pure terrorism. You cannot link what happened in NI with the IRA and on the mainland with what happens today in the "peace keeping" missions. Northern Ireland was and still is part of the United Kingdom.
I worked in London when the Harrods bomb exploded..I was so close the windows in my building rattled and we were evacuated. My partner was born and raised in Belfast and has first hand experience of terrorism as his own childhood home was firebombed when he was about 7 with him his mother and brother inside asleep. Their crime? Having a father who worked for the prison service not even guarding political prisoners. They lost everything and after the threats to the family continued, escaped to the mainland with the clothes they stood up in. He went back some years later as part of the British army.
Yes there was brutality on both sides none were without blame. But the reasons must be remembered.

austere said...

If there are repeated hate installments, like bombings and taking people hostage, how can one trust? Maybe it is genetic- one cant keep learning the same lessons all the time.


One doesn't hear too much about the British being deriled for creating two nations, it was one man's ambition and greed.At least this way North West Frontier Province isn't our problem- its the world's.

Anonymous said...

Are you looking for that great new movie that you heard so much about, but can`t find a real copy of it to download anywhere else? Let Download Gate be your guide to not only finding the movie that you want to download, but allowing you to download it at a rapid pace so you can enjoy it faster. Our extensive collection of not only the latest and greatest movies out there, but timeless classics and epic releases are just a taste of what you`ll find in our member`s area. Our staff makes sure that every new update is made available right away to our members, and that our servers can handle even the biggest rushes to download the material you desire. And you`re not going to find low quality releases here at Download Provider. Our staff also double-checks every video on our site to make sure that it`s in working order, and is delivered in good quality, so when you download it, there are no surprises on your end; just a good quality video that you can enjoy. Welcome! http://www.movies-base.com